Connect with us

Company

How real estate has performed during the pandemic

Published

on


Residential real estate has performed surprisingly well over the last year, not only during last February-March’s stock market plunge, but subsequently as well.

Is it unusual for this asset class to perform this well? It’s an important question that deserves being asked this month, the one-year anniversary of the pandemic-induced economic lockdown and bear market.

It’s important for another reason as well: Real estate represents one of the biggest chunks of U.S. households’ net worth, if not the biggest. It’s therefore of crucial relevance how residential real estate performs when the stock market plunges.

During the first quarter of last year, during which the S&P 500
SPX,
-0.06%

 lost more than 20%, the Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index rose 1.4%. Unlike bonds, which also rose during that bear market but which have struggled ever since, the Case-Shiller Index has continued to rise. Its latest reading is 8.9% higher than where it stood at the end of last year’s first quarter.

The index’s slow-and-steady march higher over the last decade is plotted in the accompanying chart. The S&P 500’s volatility is nearly six times greater than that of the Case-Shiller index (as measured by the standard deviations of their monthly returns). To be sure, part of this greater volatility is due to how the Case-Shiller index is constructed; each month’s reading reflects a three-month moving average of the raw index values. If I were to calculate the S&P 500’s volatility using the same moving-average approach, its volatility would be “only” three times greater than that of the Case-Shiller index.

Even better, from an asset allocation perspective, is that the correlation coefficient between the Case-Shiller index and the S&P 500 is close to zero.

To find out how unusual the last decade’s experience has been, I analyzed the Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price index as far back as monthly data are available (in the early 1950s). I measured this index’s performance in each U.S. equity bear market since then that appears in the calendar maintained by Ned Davis Research. If we ignore one bear market in which the index fell by a tiny amount (0.4%), it gained in every one of those bear markets—but one.

That one exception was a doozy, however: I’m referring, of course, to the 2007-2009 Great Recession. From its 2006 high to its 2012 low, the Case-Shiller index fell by 27%.

The $64,000 question, given this history, is whether real estate’s performance in the Great Recession is the exception rather than the rule. Robert Shiller, the Yale finance professor and Nobel laureate who is co-creator of this housing price index, believes it is.

In an interview in the wake of the financial crisis, Shiller told me that he thought real estate’s poor performance in the 2007-2009 was an anomalous event, since historically “there is surprisingly little relation” between home prices and the stock market. He therefore did not expect that “in the next bear stock market there [will] be anything unusual happening in the housing market.”

His prediction was certainly true in last year’s bear market. A recent email to Shiller to get his current thoughts was not immediately answered.

History therefore suggests that residential real estate will be a good hedge during the next equity bear market. Chances are that you nevertheless aren’t putting this lesson into practice in your retirement portfolio, however. That’s because we tend to pay inordinate attention to the recent past, a tendency known as “recency bias.” And this tendency is especially strong when that recent past is as traumatic as the 2007-2009 downturn.

Unless you believe that the world has changed in a fundamental way making the 2007-2009 experience the rule rather than the exception, however, you shouldn’t be underweighting real estate in your retirement portfolio.

If you decide to increase your allocation to real estate, your next challenge is figuring out how to do so. In most cases, of course, our real-estate investments are in our residence or other individual house, and their performance will be a function of a host of idiosyncratic factors in addition to a national price average like the Case-Shiller index.

It’s probably easier to say what not to do. For starters, note carefully that the historical results presented here reflect residential real estate. Commercial real estate is an entirely different kettle of fish, as we’ve seen over the last year as the work-from-home movement has inflicted horrible losses on that sector. Most of the publicly traded real-estate investment trusts invest heavily in commercial real estate, and the same goes for the exchange-traded funds that focus on real estate.

In fact, I couldn’t find any REITs or real estate ETFs whose returns are significantly correlated with the Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price index. That doesn’t mean you should automatically avoid these REITs and ETFs. But you can’t justify doing so on the basis of the history presented in this column.

Case-Shiller futures?

One way to invest directly in the residential real-estate asset class is by purchasing one of the futures contracts on the CME that are benchmarked to the Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price index. Note carefully, however, that the market for these contracts is extremely thin. Because of this, their prices can exhibit a lot of short-term volatility having more to do with the presence or absence of bids or offers than with the performance of the Case-Shiller Index itself.

For example, at the end of last year’s first quarter, the spot contract for the Case-Shiller futures contract was trading at 232.80, and at the end of May at 233. But during April the contract fell to 210 before jumping just as quickly back to where it was before. This volatility likely was due more to the market’s illiquidity than to anything else.

Another limitation to investing in Case-Shiller futures: The longest-maturity contract is just five years out. And, given the illiquidity of the market for these futures, you bear the not-inconsiderable risk of having to roll a maturing contract into a subsequent one at unfavorable prices.

At a minimum, if you are even considering the futures market to establish your residential real-estate exposure, be sure to consult a qualified adviser.

Your home

Absent that, your best residential real-estate investment option would appear to be your home or other individual home properties. Just know that you will inevitably incur lots of idiosyncratic risk with those investments. Nevertheless, the history of the Case-Shiller index suggests that you should at least consider incurring that risk.

Notice that this discussion doesn’t take into account taxes or any of a number of other estate and financial planning considerations. As always, consult with a qualified financial adviser before making any big changes.

Mark Hulbert is a regular contributor to MarketWatch. His Hulbert Ratings tracks investment newsletters that pay a flat fee to be audited. He can be reached at mark@hulbertratings.com.



Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Company

These money and investing tips can help you stay upright against the market’s headwinds

Published

on

By


Don’t miss these top money and investing features:

These money and investing stories, popular with MarketWatch readers over the past week, can give you greater knowledge about the financial markets’ current condition as you monitor your portfolio and plan ahead. Plus, check out several short videos about whether to include bitcoin and other cryptocurrency in your portfolio and how to go about it if you do.

Sign up here  to get MarketWatch’s best mutual funds and ETF stories emailed to you weekly!

INVESTING NEWS & TRENDS
A long-held investing belief — that stocks always beat bonds over the long term — turns out to be untrue

Recent history has shown that equities tend to outperform, but a review of returns back to 1793 reveals a different story.
A long-held investing belief — that stocks always beat bonds over the long term — turns out to be untrue

The Dow and the Nasdaq are diverging. Why that’s honey for stock market bears

Disconnected trading pattern hasn’t looked so ominous since the internet bubble years.
The Dow and the Nasdaq are diverging. Why that’s honey for stock market bears

Why Generation ‘I’ — YOLO investors who’ve never seen a bear market — should worry us all

First-time stock investors are making money now but market veterans know how this story ends.
Why Generation ‘I’ — YOLO investors who’ve never seen a bear market — should worry us all

5 things this index pioneer wants you to know about today’s investing challenges

Straight advice on money and market behavior from David Booth of Dimensional Fund Advisors.
5 things this index pioneer wants you to know about today’s investing challenges

Why switching investment strategies to get a market edge only leaves you behind the pack

Pick an investment plan with a good long-term record and follow it.
Why switching investment strategies to get a market edge only leaves you behind the pack

Space infrastructure is the next investment frontier and SPACs are a launch pad

The global space industry is expected to generate revenue of at least $1.4 trillion by 2030
Space infrastructure is the next investment frontier and SPACs are a launch pad

5 things to watch out for before you invest in SPACs

Similarities to the dot.com and subprime bubbles are unmistakable.
5 things to watch out for before you invest in SPACs

Long-tenured CEOs can take a business from good to great — and these companies have them

A vision for success and shareholders willing to see it through can give a business a competitive edge.
Long-tenured CEOs can take a business from good to great — and these companies have them

Franklin Templeton’s view on interest rates

Sonal Desai, CIO for Franklin Templeton’s Fixed Income Group, discusses her expectations for U.S. and global interest rates.
Franklin Templeton’s view on interest rates

Educating today’s investors about maneuvering through markets

Joe Moglia, former chairman & CEO of TD Ameritrade, discusses how investors can better maneuver volatile markets with assistance from trading platforms.
Educating today’s investors about maneuvering through markets

These 3 alternative income streams may boost portfolio returns

As traditional income strategies, like bonds and dividend stocks, got challenged by the pandemic, some investors turned to pass-through securities in search of income. Here’s what you need to know.
These 3 alternative income streams may boost portfolio returns

What Coinbase’s public debut means for bitcoin and crypto

The listing of Coinbase, the largest bitcoin exchange in the U.S., introduces a new way to invest in cryptocurrencies.
What Coinbase’s public debut means for bitcoin and crypto

Why Mike Novogratz sees bitcoin reaching $500,000 by 2024

Galaxy Digital’s Mike Novogratz explains the outlook for crypto as Coinbase goes public.
Why Mike Novogratz sees bitcoin reaching $500,000 by 2024

How to devise long-term strategies for investing in digital assets

Katie Stockton and Bryan Routledge discuss strategies and the rationale for holding crypto with Barron’s Ben Levisohn.
How to devise long-term strategies for investing in digital assets



Source link

Continue Reading

Company

Opinion: I took advantage of the 2020 RMD rule but now my 1099-R looks wrong — what should I do?

Published

on

By


Q: I took advantage of the 2020 RMD rule and returned what I had taken from my IRA thinking there would be no taxes. I just got a 1099-R showing the full RMD. That can’t be right. How do I correct it?

—Pauline

A.: Pauline,

If the 1099-R is incorrect, you will need to contact the firm that issued the statement to get it corrected. However, the 1099-R is probably correct.

Read: Are there new RMD rules this year?

Under the law, the firm issuing the 1099-R has no responsibility for reporting how much of a distribution is taxable. That responsibility rests on your shoulders as a taxpayer. The issuing firm need only report what was paid out of the IRA on 1099-R.

Not sure where to retire? Let us help you find the right spot

That does not mean you will pay any tax. Any funds returned to the IRA by Aug. 31, 2020 is considered a rollover and is not taxable. Normally, Required Minimum Distributions (RMD) are not eligible for rollover, but IRS guidance after enactment of the CARES Act that waived RMD for 2020 changed that. The guidance stated the normal 60-day time limit for rollovers would not apply and instead instituted a fixed deadline of Aug. 31, 2020 to return such distributions and avoid taxation.

Read: It’s not too late to save on your 2020 tax bill — here’s how

I get similar questions about 1099-Rs every year. The reporting of the gross distribution looks like an error but in most cases, it is correct and the person receiving it simply hasn’t learned how it is accounted for yet.

Here’s how the accounting typically works.

As with any gross amount reported on Form 1099-R, you declare the amount that is not taxable when you file your 2020 tax return. What I hear most tax preparers would do in your situation is put the gross distribution amount from 1099-R on line 4a as per the normal procedure. Then, they would place a zero in 4b of your Form 1040, and put a note on the return near those lines that it was “returned to the IRA under the CARES Act,” “CARES Act rollover,” “CARES Act,” or simply “Rollover.”

Read: These are the best new ideas in retirement

If you did not return all of distribution by the deadline, the portion that was not returned would be taxable. You would put that number on line 4b.

Read: 5 things to do if you inherit a Roth IRA

As I mentioned a moment ago, the discrepancy between the gross distribution reported and what should actually be taxable comes up in other situations. Three of the most common are other rollovers, Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCD), and distributions from accounts that had received after-tax contributions.

In all those cases, the reporting process looks like what I described above. You put the gross distribution on line 4a and the taxable portion on Line 4b. Then note why the numbers are different with “rollover,” “QCD,” or “See Form 8606” on the 1040. Form 8606 is the form used to determine the taxable amount of an IRA distribution when nondeductible contributions have been made to any of one’s IRA accounts.

If you have a question for Dan, please email him with ‘MarketWatch Q&A’ on the subject line.

Dan Moisand’s comments are for informational purposes only and are not a substitute for personalized advice. Consult your adviser about what is best for you. Some questions are edited for brevity.



Source link

Continue Reading

Company

Video: Why Mike Novogratz sees bitcoin reaching $500,000 by 2024

Published

on

By



Galaxy Digital’s Mike Novogratz explains the outlook for crypto as Coinbase goes public.





Source link

Continue Reading

Trending