Connect with us


Commodity traders profit from blockbuster year of market chaos



Commodity traders are sharing bumper spoils with their workers as the industry emerges as one of the biggest winners from the coronavirus crisis.

Trafigura’s record trading results last month provided a first glimpse of a blockbuster year for an industry dominated by a small group of mostly privately owned companies that can reap huge rewards by navigating the ups and downs of volatile commodity markets. 

Its 850 top staff received a near $600m cash windfall, bringing to $3.5bn the total paid out to partners since 2015.

“Covid hit the whole world but not every region at the same time,” said Christophe Salmon, chief financial officer. “That meant we could divert a cargo . . . to where there was a premium.”

Commodity traders are the ultimate middlemen, linking the suppliers of raw materials — often in developing countries — with consumers in wealthy and fast-growing ones, earning wafer-thin margins but on huge volumes.

Their global footprint and network of terminals, storage facilities and shipping fleets meant they were perfectly set up to capitalise when commodity prices cratered in the second quarter, according to Roland Rechtsteiner, a partner at Oliver Wyman and co-author of an annual report on the industry.

Commodity gross trading margins

In oil, the companies took advantage of panic selling to snap up cheap barrels of crude and immediately sell their cargoes forward at higher prices in the futures market, locking in almost risk-free profits.

They were also able to exploit price arbitrages caused by the spread of Covid-19. This was also evident in metals where China’s quick recovery from the pandemic boosted demand at the same time mine production in African and South America was hit by lockdowns.

Trafigura’s net income come soared 84 per cent to $1.6bn In the year to September, on turnover of $147bn. In oil trading — a market whose huge swings took US crude prices briefly negative in April, gross profits surged threefold to a record $5.3bn, while in metals they jumped 30 per cent to $1.53bn.

Other traders are also on track to notch up big profits for 2020. Glencore’s trading arm reported a doubling of earnings before interest in the six months to June to a record $2bn, while net income at Mercuria was a record $277m in the second quarter.

Senior traders and executives said the structure of the oil market was the biggest factor behind the industry’s performance last year.

China’s quick recovery from the pandemic boosted demand for metals at the same time as mine production in African and South America was hit by lockdowns © TPG/Getty

Gunvor CEO Torbjörn Törnqvist said 2020 had been a good year for the Geneva-based company, although it had taken impairment charges on its refineries owing to the pandemic. Trafigura also recorded $1.5bn in writedowns and impairments against the value of its industrial assets.

“In terms of gross profit we did very well and our balance sheet is stronger,” said Mr Törnqvist, adding that the second quarter of 2020 was probably the “best on record for the industry.”

“I am not sure we will see those conditions again. Between the Opec-Russia price war and collapse in demand, it was a perfect storm. Every trading house made a lot of money.”

Trafigura’s partners windfall

Senior traders and executives including Russell Hardy, chief executive of the world’s biggest independent oil trader Vitol, said the structure of the oil market was the biggest factor behind the industry’s strong performance in 2020.

“If you had been here in 2008-09 you knew what to do because it was the same structure,” said Mr Hardy, referring to the oil market “contango” — when longer-dated futures prices trade at higher levels than near-term counterparts — that boosted profits across the industry in the aftermath of the global financial crisis.

Mr Rechtsteiner said 2021 was likely be another good year for the industry because markets remained choppy and there was a wider range of possible outcomes.

“My expectation is that we are going to see a lot of volatility over the coming quarters,” he said. “We are starting to deploy vaccines but we don’t know how effective they will be and how they will change behaviour. It could be a very interesting year.”

However, the industry is facing increased regulatory scrutiny and questions about business practices, in particular the use of agents to win business.

Physical commodity trading often involves operating in countries that have been hotbeds of corruption, or where it is difficult to secure business without agents who network with government officials to help land deals.

The Opec-Russia oil price war and collapse in demand was a perfect storm that enabled trading houses to make a lot of money © Patrick T. Fallon/Bloomberg

Last month Vitol agreed to pay over $160m to authorities in the US and Brazil after admitting bribery in three countries and trying to manipulate oil benchmarks. Glencore and Trafigura are also facing corruption probes.

“Historically, corruption and bribery have no doubt been endemic across the commodity trading industry and our investigation into Vitol and its competitors’ acts in Brazil alone revealed a mass of squalid deals,” said Ed Davey of campaign group Global Witness.

Although the sector is moving away from the use of middlemen, Jean-Francois Lambert, a consultant and former trade finance banker, said the investigations would be a concern for all stakeholders including banks, which extend huge amounts of credit to the sector.

“Corruption allegations involving one trading house stain the whole sector,” said Mr Lambert. “Collective discipline is therefore no longer an option but a necessity.”

Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Oil price jumps above $70 after attacks aimed at Saudi oil facilities




Oil prices jumped above $70 a barrel for the first time in 14 months after Saudi Arabia, the world’s top oil exporter, said its energy facilities had been attacked on Sunday, targeting “the security and stability” of global supplies.

A drone attack from the sea on a petroleum storage tank at Ras Tanura, one of the largest oil shipping ports in the world, took place on Sunday morning, the kingdom said.

In the evening, shrapnel from a ballistic missile fell in Dhahran, where state oil company Saudi Aramco has its headquarters and near where thousands of employees and their families live.

While Saudi Arabia’s ministry of energy said the attacks “did not result in any injury or loss of life or property”, and a person familiar with the matter said no production had been affected, the attacks have still unsettled oil markets that have rebounded strongly in recent months.

Brent crude, the international benchmark, rose 2 per cent to a high of $71.16 a barrel while West Texas Intermediate, the US benchmark, rose by a similar amount to a high of $67.86 a barrel.

Yemen’s Iran-allied Houthi fighters claimed responsibility for the attacks and said they had also focused on military targets in the Saudi cities of Dammam, Asir and Jazan.

A Houthi military spokesperson said the group had fired 14 bomb-laden drones and eight ballistic missiles in a “wide operation in the heart of Saudi Arabia”.

Amrita Sen at Energy Aspects emphasised that while a direct hit on oil supplies appeared to have been avoided, the threat to the market would still be taken seriously by oil traders.

“The oil price was already on a strong footing after Saudi Arabia and Opec’s decision last week to keep restricting production,” she said.

Brent crude, the international oil benchmark, has risen close to $70 a barrel since the cartel and allies outside the group, including Russia, decided not to unleash a flood of crude on to the market.

Amid uncertainty about the oil market outlook as the coronavirus crisis continues to have an impact on crude demand, the group decided against raising production by 1.5m barrels a day from April.

Given the supply curbs, while the kingdom has the extra production capacity to tap into, “geopolitical threats to supply will add a premium to the price”, Sen added.

The kingdom’s state media outlet said earlier in the day that the Saudi-led military coalition confronting the Houthis had intercepted missiles and drones aimed at “civilian targets” without indicating their location.

The Eastern Province, where Dhahran is located, is where much of Saudi Aramco’s oil facilities are located. The attack is the most severe since September 2019.

At that time the kingdom was rocked by missile and drone fire that hit an important processing facility and two oilfields, temporarily shutting off more than half of the country’s crude output.

The Houthis have ramped up assaults on Saudi Arabia through airborne attacks and explosive-laden boats and mines in the Red Sea, laying bare the vulnerability of the country’s energy infrastructure despite the kingdom’s production prowess and its hold over the oil market.

“The frequency of these attacks is rising, even if the impact on energy infrastructure appears limited,” said Bill Farren-Price, a director at research company Enverus. “We know the capacity to cause serious damage exists, so this will boost the risk premium for oil.”

Source link

Continue Reading


Rio Tinto set to start negotiations over Mongolian mine




Rio Tinto is set to start face-to-face negotiations with the government of Mongolia as its seeks to complete the $6.75bn expansion of a huge copper project in the Gobi desert. 

The Anglo-Australian group is sending a team of senior executives to the capital Ulaanbaatar to try and hammer out a new financing agreement so that the development timeline can be maintained and underground caving operations can start later this year.

The discussions will focus on a number of issues including tax, a new power agreement and benefit sharing, according to people with knowledge of the situation.

Some government officials want Rio to pay more than $300m of withholding taxes on income it has received from Oyu Tolgoi LLC, the Mongolian holding company that owns the mine. 

Rio receives a management service fee for running Oyu Tolgoi’s existing open pit and the underground project as well as interest on money it has lent the government to fund its share of the development costs.

However, the officials say it is “very difficult, if not impossible” to engage constructively on the issue because the payments are the subject of arbitration in London.

For its part, Rio believes the issue of withholding taxes is dealt with in the separate investment and shareholder agreements that cover its operations in the country.

The underground expansion of Oyu Tolgoi ranks as Rio’s most important growth project. At peak production it will be one of the world’s biggest copper mines, producing almost 500,000 tonnes a year.

Although Rio runs the existing operations and is in charge of the underground expansion project it does not have a direct stake in the mine.

It’s exposure comes through a 51 per cent stake in Turquoise Hill Resources, a Toronto-listed company. TRQ in turns owns 66 per cent of Oyu Tolgoi LLC, with the rest controlled by the government of Mongolia. 

The project has been beset by difficulties and is already two years late and $1.5bn over budget. The government said earlier this year that if the expansion is not economically beneficial to the country it would be necessary to “review and evaluate” whether it can proceed.

To that end the ruling Mongolian People’s party and its new prime minister Luvsannamsrain Oyun-Erdene are trying to replace the Underground Development Plan with an improved agreement.

Signed in 2015, this sets out the fees that Rio receives for managing the project as well as the interest rates on the cash Mongolia has borrowed to finance its share of construction costs.

However, it was never approved by Mongolia’s parliament and has become a focal point for critics who say the country should receive a greater share of the financial benefits.

Rio, which recently appointed a new chief executive, has told the government it is prepared to “explore” a reduction of its project management fees and loan interest rates as well as discuss tax.

However, analysts are sceptical that the two sides will be able to put a new agreement in place by June when a decision on whether to start caving operations must be taken if Oyu Tolgoi is to meet a new target for first production in October 2022.

Rio is also at loggerheads with TRQ on how to fund the cost overruns at Oyu Tolgoi. Last week, TRQ’s chief executive resigned after Rio said it planned to vote against his re-election at its annual shareholders’ meeting.

In a statement, Rio said it was committed to working with TRQ and the government of Mongolia to enable the successful delivery of the Oyu Tolgoi Project

“Aligning and co-ordinating our joint efforts to resolve the concerns of the Government . . . going forward is of the highest priority,” it said.

Source link

Continue Reading


Value investor John Rogers sees an end to Big Tech’s stock market dominance




The veteran value investor John Rogers predicted the US is headed for a repeat of the “roaring twenties” a century ago that will finally encourage investors to dump tech stocks in favour of companies more sensitive to the economy.

The founder of Ariel Investments told the Financial Times in an interview that value investing “dinosaurs” like him stood to win as higher economic growth and rising interest rates took the air out of some of the hottest stocks of recent years.

Rogers, who has spent a near four-decade career focused on buying under-appreciated stocks, said the frenzied buying of special purpose acquisition companies, or Spacs, signalled frothiness in parts of the market, even while a coming economic boom underpinned other share prices.

“This will be a sustainable recovery. I think there’s going to be kind of a roaring twenties again,” Rogers said, adding that the strength of the economic recovery would surprise people and challenge the Federal Reserve’s ultra-dovish monetary policy.

The US central bank is “overly optimistic that they can keep inflation under control”, he said, and higher bond market interest rates would reduce the value of future earnings for highly popular growth stocks such as tech companies and for the kinds of speculative companies coming to market in initial public offerings or via deals with Spacs.

“Spacs are a sign that growth stocks are topping. A signal that the market is frothy,” said Rogers, a self-styled contrarian and famed for his Patient Investor newsletter for clients that debuted in 1983.

Value investing is based on identifying cheap companies that are trading below their true worth, an approach long espoused by Warren Buffett. Value stocks and those sensitive to the economic cycle boomed after the internet bubble burst in 2000, but the investment strategy has been well beaten over the past decade by fast-growing stocks, led by US tech giants. 

“We’ve been looking like the dinosaurs for so long,” said Rogers. “We’ve been waiting for that booming economic recovery since 2009.”

Proponents of value investing believe that the combination of expensive growth stock valuations and a robust recovery from the pandemic will cause a significant switch between the two investing approaches.

Higher bond market interest rates reduce the relative appeal of owning growth stocks based on their future earnings power.

When 10-year bond yields rise, “growth stocks look way, way too expensive versus value,” said Rogers. “Value stocks are going to come out of the recovery very strong, they’re going to have a tailwind from an earnings perspective. Their earnings are going to be here and now, not 20, 30 years down the road.”

The Russell 1000 Value index outperformed the equivalent growth index by 6 percentage points in February, rising 5.8 per cent versus a drop of 0.1 per cent for the growth index. That was the biggest outperformance for value since March 2001, according to analysts at Bank of America.

“Although rising rates triggered the rotation, we see a host of other reasons to prefer value over growth,” the analysts wrote last week, “including the profit cycle, valuation, and positioning that can drive further outperformance.”

Rogers said he expected higher overall stock market volatility from rising interest rates this year but value should reward investors as it did “20 years ago once the internet bubble burst”. Ariel is bullish on “fee generating financials” and Rogers said preferred names included KKR, Lazard and Janus Henderson, while it was also bullish on traditional media, including CBS Viacom and Nielsen.

Chicago-based Ariel is one of the few large black-owned investment companies in the US, with $15bn of assets under management. It manages the oldest US mid-cap value fund, dating from 1986. 

Source link

Continue Reading