Connect with us

Company

The FOMC and Fed governors have become less important as decision-making revolves around Chairman Powell

Published

on


Be careful what you wish for. The Federal Reserve nowadays is much more transparent in policy setting and implementing than it was, but increased openness does not always lead to better decision making. 

Changes that let sunshine into some areas have cast a shadow on other avenues of the Fed’s communications and impeded its deliberations. They also tilt the balance of policy-making authority further to the center — with all the risks that concentration of power entails.

A long, long time ago in a financial galaxy far, far away, the Fed was cloistered, close-mouthed, and confusing to the general public. The institution was so viewed as walled-up that William Greider’s “The Secrets of the Temple” was a best-seller. For example, before the first policy announcement in February 1994, the Fed signaled changes in the policy rate through the type of open market operation its Domestic Desk conducted the day after a meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC). In 1995, it beefed up the minutes released after each meeting and began preparing transcripts with a five-year publication lag. 

In those days, the transcripts were viewed as a resource for historians and a mechanism for outside doubters to test the veracity of the minutes, albeit well after the fact. In the event, these changes blew back on the quality of deliberations at FOMC meetings and public understanding of policy. Alternative drafts of the statement circulated in advance of the meeting, channeling the conversation in preset directions. The minutes were published with a sufficient lag to sometimes be unrepresentative of current Fed thinking. Knowledge that their remarks would be under future scrutiny led FOMC participants to prepare them in advance and eschew improvisation. The result was longer and more scripted meetings.  

Fast-forward to the present — press conferences by the chairman after each meeting strive for new heights of openness. But here too, human nature intercedes to create problems.

First, during an FOMC meeting, the group can relegate difficult issues in conveying policy nuance in the single sheet of paper that is their statement to the chairman’s more expansive opening remarks at the press conference. Rather than smoothing the sharp edges of their differences in a statement voted upon, they rely on the chairman to relate a central, but more diffuse, message for which they are not personally held to account. As a result, the FOMC statement has become less important.

Second, having summarized in the press conference the range of opinions expressed by participants, the chairman sucks the oxygen out of the public space for other official speakers. The Fed governors and Bank presidents who line up for the media are gauged on how close they hew to the party line. So speeches and other remarks by other officials are less important.

Third, the chairman’s press-conference remarks represent a first draft of monetary policy history, a role previously served by the FOMC minutes. To an important extent, the press conference remarks, prepared in a tight window around the meeting, constrain any independent staff review of the FOMC’s conversation, as the chairman has already weighed in as to what was important. As a result, the FOMC minutes are less important.

To the extent that the press conference gets information out earlier is all to the good. To the extent that the chairman’s real-time interpretation puts guard rails around subsequent consideration of the FOMC’s discussion, something is lost. Something is also lost as the center of attention shifts further to one official — the chairman.

Chairman Powell has not just opened the doors and windows of the Fed, he often leaves the Temple.  On Powell’s watch, officials so far have conducted 15 “Fed Listens” events with the general public across the country. Powell has also visited Capitol Hill far more frequently than any of his predecessors. 

More light on the matter can only be for the good, right? Except, once again, the spotlight is narrow. The chairman in town is the big news during the Fed Listens town halls. Moreover, the chairman is building personal rapport with members of the Congress that can not be replicated by others in his policy committee.

This is not to doubt the chairman’s motives, as Powell seems sincere in his desire to strengthen the Fed’s democratic legitimacy. After all, an institutional creature of the Congress needs the ongoing support of elected officials and the voters that put them there. The result of this increased sunshine is to render Powell the Sun King of monetary policy. A chair-centric committee can work for the public good — consider Paul Volcker and Alan Greenspan — or not, as with Arthur Burns.

A few years before his elevation to chairman, Powell, then a Fed governor, had the courage to represent the Fed at a relatively pointed event at the Brookings Institution on “Fedspeak.” His advice was to sort through the chaff of Fed communication and understand that “there is a single FOMC participant who has most of the leverage in our policy discussions.” Jay Powell has become that person — and more.

Vincent Reinhart is chief economist and macro strategist at Mellon. He worked 24 years at the Federal Reserve in various roles including secretary and economist of the FOMC.

More:Powell says U.S. economy needs more fiscal support

Plus: ‘The 25-cent solution’ would have prevented the COVID recession, says the most accurate economic forecaster

 



Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Company

These money and investing tips can help you with stock and bond strategies to whip inflation

Published

on

By


Don’t miss these top money and investing features:

These money and investing stories, popular with MarketWatch readers over the past week, can help you prepare your portfolio for a period of higher inflation — transitory or not.

Sign up here to get MarketWatch’s best mutual funds and ETF stories emailed to you weekly!



Source link

Continue Reading

Company

These money and investing tips can shine some light through the stock market’s ‘June gloom’

Published

on

By


Don’t miss these top money and investing features:

These money and investing stories, popular with MarketWatch readers over the past week, can help your decision-making if the market outlook becomes cloudier and momentum starts to fade — even as the outlook for the post-pandemic economy gets clearer.

Sign up here to get MarketWatch’s best mutual funds and ETF stories emailed to you weekly!



Source link

Continue Reading

Company

These money and investing tips can help you stay belted in when stocks get on a roller coaster

Published

on

By


Don’t miss these top money and investing features:

These money and investing stories, popular with MarketWatch readers over the past week, give you a 360-degree view of opportunities and strategies to capitalize on in case stocks go into a June swoon.

Sign up here to get MarketWatch’s best mutual funds and ETF stories emailed to you weekly!

INVESTING NEWS & TRENDS
Dow 37,000? It’s possible if U.S. stocks stage an ‘average’ summer rally

Dow Jones Industrial Average has gained 7% on average between the beginning of June and the end of August.
Dow 37,000? It’s possible if U.S. stocks stage an ‘average’ summer rally

Why it matters to the stock if Facebook is a tech company or a media play

In one of these industries Facebook shares are undervalued, which influences the stock price.
Why it matters to the stock if Facebook is a tech company or a media play

Small-cap stocks will go nowhere over the next year, according to the indicator with the best track record

Still, the gauge has been too bearish as smaller companies rally.
Small-cap stocks will go nowhere over the next year, according to the indicator with the best track record

These cool, high-quality stocks are just right for this overheated, overvalued market

Well-managed companies boast strong cash flow, a stable shareholder base, and are under most investors’ radar.
These cool, high-quality stocks are just right for this overheated, overvalued market

Investors should own these four sectors as the economic recovery plays out: SPDR U.S. chief strategist

Michael Arone of State Street Global Advisors recommends owning cyclical stocks in the financial, energy, materials and industrial sectors.
Investors should own these four sectors as the economic recovery plays out: SPDR U.S. chief strategist

It really is different this time — a new era for stocks is just getting started

Why you can’t expect the stock market’s future to look anything like the past.
It really is different this time — a new era for stocks is just getting started

Life might feel more certain this summer, but betting on a calm stock market still could go wrong

Record margin balances to messy economic data may keep investors holding their breath.
Life might feel more certain this summer, but betting on a calm stock market still could go wrong

When claiming Social Security at age 66 makes sense

The conventional wisdom to always wait until age 70 isn’t always right
When claiming Social Security at age 66 makes sense

If your financial adviser is giving you fits, it might be time to break up

Advisers have to be attentive to clients or risk losing them.
If your financial adviser is giving you fits, it might be time to break up

Bitcoin holders have no choice but to trust in Chinese crypto miners

Two-thirds of the world’s bitcoin mining power is based in China, leaving the cryptocurrency potentially vulnerable.
Bitcoin holders have no choice but to trust in Chinese crypto miners

A reality check on inflation

Art Hogan, chief market strategist for National Securities, discusses fluctuations in the cost of industrial materials.

A reality check on inflation

Bitcoin volatility signals a long road to adoption

China’s recent warning on cryptocurrency sent the market in a tailspin. WSJ’s Aaron Back explains why the recent shake-ups in the value of bitcoin, dogecoin, ether and other cryptocurrencies may point to obstacles in mainstream acceptance.
Bitcoin volatility signals a long road to adoption

3 ways to promote racial equity with your investments

Here’s how to apply a racial equity lens to your portfolio in order to support racial justice with your investments, while at the same time meeting your personal financial goals.
3 ways to promote racial equity with your investments

What you need to know about the race to the first Bitcoin ETF

Cryptocurrency skeptics and supporters have cited benefits and concerns about what the approval of a bitcoin ETF may mean for investors.
What you need to know about the race to the first Bitcoin ETF



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending